Primer on the General Schedule Pay Structure

SPEAKERS
Melissa Brehe, OPM
Allan Hearne, OPM
Jerry Mikowicz, OPM


Who Does the General Schedule Represent?

  • Department of Housing and Urban Development
  • General Services Administration
  • Department of Energy
  • Department of Labor
  • National Aeronautics and Space Administration
  • Department of Commerce
  • Department of Health
  • Department of the Interior
  • Social Security Administration
  • Department of the Navy
  • Department of the Air Force
  • Department of Defense
  • Department of Justice
  • Department of the Army
  • Department of the Treasury
  • Department of Veterans Affairs
  • Department of Agriculture
  • Department of Energy
  • Department of State
  • and many more

What Does the General Schedule Look Like?
2000 General Schedule Pay Rates
(Excluding Locality Pay Rates)

[Table of the General Schedule follows showing rates for Grades GS-1 through 15, 10 steps per grade, and an annotation that there is a 30 percent pay range per grade.]

Major Features of the
GS Pay System (1)

  • Pay Linked to Classification and Contributions

    • equal pay for substantially equal work

    • variations in rates of pay based on
      • difficulty, responsibility, and qualification requirements of the work
      • contributions of employees to efficiency and economy in the service
      [Classification Policy (5 U.S.C. 5101)]

    • appropriate incentives and recognition for excellence in performance
      [Merit System Principles (5 U.S.C. 2301(b)(3))]

Major Features of the
GS Pay System (2)

  • Single white-collar system covering most employees
    • Separate blue-collar system
    • Separate senior management/senior level system
    • Special systems, special rates

  • Single job-grading system
    • 15 grades (formerly 18 grades)
    • Some agencies outside of the General Schedule have more or less than 15 grades [example: the Foreign Service, another statutory pay system, has 9 classes (grades)]

Major Features of the
GS Pay System (3)

  • Single pay plan
    • The General Schedule pay plan code is GS; other structures may look like GS (e.g. GG), but differences exist.
    • GS covers about 70 percent of the executive branch
    • There are about 160 pay plans in the executive branch

What Does the General Schedule Accomplish?

Allows Government to deal systematically and fairly with:

A. Internal Equity

B. External Competitiveness

C. Individual Pay Progression

How Does a Formal Grade Structure Link to Pay? (1)

  • The Classification System facilitates all other aspects of personnel management

  • The classification structure is fixed

  • Pay is variable

How Does a Formal Grade Structure Link to Pay? (2)

[Table showing FES Points and 2000 GS Pay Range for each GS Grade.]

General Schedule Pay Structure

  • 15 grades (definitions in 5 U.S.C 5104)
  • 10 steps per grade
  • 30 percent pay range per grade and overlapping pay ranges
  • Inter-grade differential
    • Job intervals for one-grade series
    • Job intervals for two-grade series
    • Declining percentage grade differentials
  • Shape of pay structure
    • Exponential curve

Grades: One-Grade Interval Work

[From table:]

One-Grade Inter-Grade Differential

From (Midpoint) GS-1 to (Midpoint) GS-2 -- Percent: 12.4%
From (Midpoint) GS-2 to (Midpoint) GS-3 -- Percent: 9.1%
From (Midpoint) GS-3 to (Midpoint) GS-4 -- Percent: 12.3%
From (Midpoint) GS-4 to (Midpoint) GS-5 -- Percent: 11.9%
From (Midpoint) GS-5 to (Midpoint) GS-6 -- Percent: 11.5%
From (Midpoint) GS-6 to (Midpoint) GS-7 -- Percent: 11.1%
From (Midpoint) GS-7 to (Midpoint) GS-8 -- Percent: 10.8%
From (Midpoint) GS-8 to (Midpoint) GS-9 -- Percent: 10.5%
From (Midpoint) GS-9 to (Midpoint) GS-10 -- Percent: 10.1%
From (Midpoint) GS-10 to (Midpoint) GS-11 -- Percent: 9.9%

[Chart shows bars representing the approximate salary range for grades 1 through 11.]

Grades: Two-Grade Interval Work

[From table:]

Two-Grade Inter-Grade Differential

From (Midpoint) GS-5 to (Midpoint) GS-7 -- Percent: 23.9%
From (Midpoint) GS-7 to (Midpoint) GS-9 -- Percent: 22.3%
From (Midpoint) GS-9 to (Midpoint) GS-11 -- Percent: 21.0%
From (Midpoint) GS-11 to (Midpoint) GS-12 -- Percent: 19.9%
From (Midpoint) GS-12 to (Midpoint) GS-13 -- Percent: 18.9%
From (Midpoint) GS-13 to (Midpoint) GS-14 -- Percent: 18.2%
From (Midpoint) GS-14 to (Midpoint) GS-15 -- Percent: 17.6%

[Chart shows bars representing the approximate salary range for grades 5, 7, 9, and 11 through 15.]

Grades: Example of Career Ladder Pay Progression
GS-5 to GS-11 Professional versus Full Performance GS-5 Clerical

[Chart showing salary progression for Professional from approximately $16,000 to approximately $48,000 during the years 1990 to 2000, and salary progression for Clerical (Full Performance) from approximately $16,000 to approximately $28,000 during the same span.]

Pay Range Theory and Practice

  • Range spreads usually vary based on the level and sophistication of skills required for a position. Entry-level positions that require skills that are quickly mastered usually have narrower pay ranges than supervisory, managerial, or high-level technical positions.

  • Individuals in lower-level positions not only master the requirements of the job sooner, they also have a greater number of opportunities over time to be promoted to higher-level positions. Senior-level positions require a longer learning curve and often have limited opportunities for advancement. (WorldatWork)

Pay Ranges versus Pay Grades

  • Narrow pay ranges and more grades allow for more frequent promotions-and a greater perception of growth and advancement-than wider ranges and fewer grades. (WorldatWork)

[Graph illustrating pay for each GS grade (1 through 15) and pay for Junior, Mid, Journey, and Senior ranges. The Junior range encompasses grades 1 through 4; the Mid range encompasses grades 5 through 8; the Journey range encompasses grades 9 through 12; and the Senior range encompasses grades 13 through 15.]

Federal Pay Range Patterns

Pay System: Federal Wage System
Characteristics: Nonexempt Production and Maintenance
Range Spread: 16.7 percent

Pay System: General Schedule
Characteristics: Professional, Administrative, Technical, Clerical, and Officer
Range Spread: 30 percent

Pay System: Foreign Service
Characteristics: Officers and Support Personnel
Range Spread: 47 percent

Pay System: Demonstration Project- China Lake
Characteristics: Scientific and Engineering and Senior Professional Staff
Range Spread: Band III - 55%

Pay System: Senior Executive Service
Characteristics: Executive Level Management
Range Spread: No Range - Rank-in-Person

Private Sector Pay Range Patterns

Characteristics: lower-level service, production, and maintenance
Common Pay Range: 20-25 percent

Characteristics: clerical, technical, paraprofessional
Common Pay Range: 30-40 percent

Characteristics: professional, administrative, and middle management
Common Pay Range: 40-50 percent

Characteristics: higher-level managerial, executive, and technical
Common Pay Range: 50 percent and up

(WorldatWork)

Federal Pay Range Spread (1)

  • General Schedule Steps
    • Uniform dollar amount
    • Calculated as 3.33 percent of the step 1 rate
    • Declining percentage

        Step 1
        plus 3.3 percent = Step 2
        plus 3.2 percent = Step 3
        plus 3.1 percent = Step 4
        plus 3.0 percent = Step 5
        plus 2.9 percent = Step 6
        plus 2.9 percent = Step 7
        plus 2.8 percent = Step 8
        plus 2.7 percent = Step 9
        plus 2.6 percent = Step 10

Federal Pay Range Spread (2)

  • Foreign Service Steps
    • Uniform percentage amount
    • Calculated as 3 percent of previous step

        Step 1
        plus 3 percent = Step 2
        plus 3 percent = Step 3
        plus 3 percent = Step 4
        ...
        plus 3 percent = Step 12
        plus 3 percent = Step 13
        plus 3 percent = Step 14

Federal Pay Range Spread (3)

Foreign Service Pay Ranges

  • The Foreign Service pay system has about a 47 percent range with intergrade differentials of 12 percent for class 9 through 5 and 23 percent for classes 5 through 1. There is a great deal of overlap between levels.

[Graph showing pay blocks for classes 9 through 1, capped at GS-15, Step 10.]

    Federal Pay Range Spread (4)

    • Federal Wage System Steps
      • A uniform percent of step 2 rate, but a declining percentage system
      • Calculated as 4 percent of the step 2 rate
      • Step 2 represents the prevailing wage rate for the survey locality

          Step 1, 96 percent of the prevailing rate

          plus 4.17 percent = Step 2, 100 percent of the prevailing rate

          plus 4.00 percent = Step 3, 104 percent of the prevailing rate

          plus 3.85 percent = Step 4, 108 percent of the prevailing rate

          plus 3.70 percent = Step 5, 112 percent of the prevailing rate

    Federal Pay Range Spread (5)

    Special Pay Structures for Special Rate Ranges

    • Last resort for staffing problems
    • Labor market supply and demand dynamics
    • Influenced by non-Federal pay rates
    • Links to the GS pay structure

    General Schedule Rates versus Maximum Special Rates

    [Graph with vertical axis labeled "Salary" showing levels from $0 to $70,000 in $10,000 increments, and with horizontal axis labeled "Step" showing steps 1 through 10. The graph shows GS-9 Base Rates in the $32,000 to $42,000 range represented as points on the graph, ascending on a line in relation to the steps. Above is a similar ascending line representing Maximum Special Rates at the same steps, demonstrating a 67 percent increase over the GS-9 base rate on the left side (step 1) and a 51 percent increase on the right side (step 10).]

    Analysis of Pay Structures: Comparative Measures

    • Measures of Pay Structure
      • Midpoint
      • Compa Ratio
      • Minimum-Maximum
    • Measures of Workforce Distribution
      • Step Distribution
      • Weighted Average

    Comparative Measures (1)

    • The private sector uses midpoint differentials to construct pay ranges and compa ratios to control costs.

    Midpoint differentials show the difference in midpoints between two grades. [Graphic showing a rectangle labeled "Grade A" and a similar rectangle labeled "Grade B," with "20% Range" noted below. The "Grade A" rectangle is inset and a line is drawn from its midpoint to the midpoint of the "Grade B" rectangle, showing a midpoint differential of 10%.]

    Compa ratios compare individual employee pay to the pay range midpoint.

    Example: An employees pay is $14,000.
    The pay range midpoint is $15,000.
    The ratio between the employees pay and the midpoint is $14,000/$15,000.
    The employees compa ratio is 93%.

    Comparative Measures (2)

    • Grade overlap is the amount by which the pay of one grade overlaps an adjacent grade.

    • Grade overlap is minimal when midpoint differentials are large and range widths are small. Grade overlap is significant when midpoint differentials are small and range spread is large. (WorldatWork)

    [Graphic showing the following:]

    Minimal Grade Overlap: 20% range spread - 25% midpoint differential

    General Schedule Grade Overlap: GS-14 and GS-15, 30% range spread - 17.6 midpoint differential

    Significant Grade Overlap: 50% range spread - 10% midpoint differential

    Comparative Measures (3)

    • Since the General Schedule is adjusted by a single uniform percentage (5 U.S.C. 5303), the current inter-grade differentials are frozen in place. (See charts for one-and two-grade interval work for GS intergrade differentials.)

    • The structural and individual pay mechanisms of the General Schedule do not require Federal managers to calculate compa ratios as part of the pay-setting process.

    How Employees Move Within the GS Pay Structure (1)

    • Within-grade increases
      • Time in grade
      • Satisfactory performance (acceptable level of competence)
      • Virtually automatic progression
      • Learning curve theory

    • Quality step increases
      • Outstanding performance
      • Not more than once every 52 weeks
      • Does not affect time in grade for next within-grade increase

    General Schedule Steps

    • 30 percent rate range

    • Uniform dollar within-grade step increases
      • 3.3 % of step one rate
      • 2.6 % of step nine rate

    • Grades 1 and 2 out-of-alignment

      [Graph showing Grade 9 salary at each step.]

    Illustration of General Schedule Step Progression

    [Similar graphs labeled "Grade 9 (Steps)" and "Grade 9 (Power Curve)." The vertical axis of each shows $30,000 to $45,000 in $5000 increments; the horizontal axis of each shows years 0 to 18. Points representing step progression are shown on an ascending line on each graph. The line on the "Grade 9 (Steps)" graph has plateaus; the line on the "Grade 9 (Power Curve)" graph follows the same course but in ascending increments without the plateaus.

    Employment Distribution by Step GS-3

    [Bar chart: Vertical axis is labeled "Employment" and ascends from 0 to 7,500 in increments of 1,500. Horizontal axis shows steps 1 through 10. The bar for step 1 ascends to 6,000. The bars for steps 2 through 9 are at 750 or below. The bar for step 10 ascends to 1,500.]

    Employment Distribution by Step GS-9

    [Bar chart: Vertical axis is labeled "Employment" and ascends from 0 to 20,000 in increments of 4,000. Horizontal axis shows steps 1 through 10. The bar for step 1 ascends between 16,000 and 20,000. The bars for steps 2 through 10 ascend between 6,000 and 16,000.]

    Employment Distribution by Step GS-15 (Excludes GM)

    [Bar chart: Vertical axis is labeled "Employment" and ascends from 0 to 5,000 in increments of 1,000. Horizontal axis shows steps 1 through 10. The bars for step 1, 2, 3, 8, and 9 ascend between 1,000 and 2,000. The bars for steps 4 through 7 ascend between 3,000 and 4,000. The bar for step 10 ascends above 4,000.]

    Employment Distribution by Step All Grades

    [Bar chart: Vertical axis is labeled "Employment" and ascends from 20,000 to 180,000 in increments of 20,000. Horizontal axis shows steps 1 through 10. The bar for step 1 ascends to 140,000. The bars for steps 2 and 3 ascend between 60,000 and 80,000. The bars for steps 4, 5, and 6 ascend between 120,000 and 140,000. The bar for step 7 ascends between 140,000 and 160,000. The bar for step 8 ascends between 100,000 and 120,000. The bar for step 9 ascends between 60,000 and 80,000. The bar for step 10 ascends between 140,000 and 160,000.]

    How Employees Move Within the GS Pay Structure (2)

    • Promotions
      • Career ladder or merit promotion
      • Minimum two-step increase
        Examples:
        • GS-9, step 1 promoted to GS-11
          • $32,380 to $39,178 (GS-11, step 1)
            amount $ = $6,798; amount % = 20.99%

        • GS-9, step 5 promoted to GS-11
          • $36,696 to $39,178 (GS-11, step 1)
            amount $ = $2,482; amount % = 6.76%

        • GS-9, step 10 promoted to GS-11
          • $42,091 to $44,402 (GS-11, step 5)
            amount $ = $2,311; amount % = 5.49%

    How Employees Move Within the GS Pay Structure (3)

    • Alternative methods for determining individual pay rates and range progression
      • single rate
      • skill-based pay/competencies
      • automatic step rates/longevity
      • performance-based step rates
      • step rate and merit based pay
      • variable merit performance-based pay
      • structural versus individual adjustments
      • uniform or variable timing

    A Private Sector Model for Pay Range Progression and Performance

    [Graph: vertical axis shows percentage of pay range progression; horizontal axis represents time (no increments specified). Lines angle from the horizontal axis to the following performance levels and percentages of pay range progression:]

    Outstanding - 100%
    Excellent - 75%
    Very Good - 50%
    Good - 25%
    Poor - 0%

    Comparison of Shape of 1949 and 2000 General Schedule

    [Graph with vertical axis labeled "Salary" showing levels from $0 to $12,000 in $2,000 increments, and with horizontal axis labeled "Grade" showing grades 1 through 15. The graph shows a line labeled "2000 Min" ascending from beneath the $2000 level at Grade 1 to the $8000 level at grade 15. Above is another line, labeled "1949 Min," that ascends from just above the $2000 level at Grade 1 to the $10,000 level at grade 15. A line of text below the chart reads: Note: GS 2000 pay rates are divided by a factor of 10.]

    Structural Pay Increases

    • The shape of the 1949 and 2000 General Schedule are similar. However, pay for higher grades has increased somewhat faster than at lower grades.
      • GS-5 increased 689 percent between 1949 and 2000
      • GS-13 increase 734 percent between 1949 and 2000

    • Most annual pay adjustments have been a uniform percent across-the-board schedule increase. Intergrade differentials have remained fairly constant.

    • Structural pay costs are controlled by the President and Congress, not individual agencies.

    • Timing cycle
      • salary survey
      • recommendations
      • approval/Federal budget process
      • implementation

    Current Perspectives (1)

    • General Schedule Structural Adjustments

      • General adjustment - based on annual change in employment cost index (ECI) as of September 30 minus 0.5 points

      • Locality adjustments - based on Bureau of Labor Statistics salary surveys in 32 localities

      • Measured, prepared, and analyzed centrally

      • Agencies implement

      • President and Congress make final decisions

    ECI and Locality Pay Increases

    1994: ECI-Based Adjustment: 0.00%, Locality Average Rate: 3.95%
    1995: ECI-Based Adjustment: 2.00%, Locality Average Rate: 5.05%
    1996: ECI-Based Adjustment: 2.00%, Locality Average Rate: 5.56%
    1997: ECI-Based Adjustment: 2.30%, Locality Average Rate: 6.38%
    1998: ECI-Based Adjustment: 2.30%, Locality Average Rate: 6.93%
    1999: ECI-Based Adjustment: 3.10%, Locality Average Rate: 7.50%
    2000: ECI-Based Adjustment: 3.80%, Locality Average Rate: 8.62%

    1994: ECI of 2.2% canceled. Full locality pay.
    1995: ECI of 2.6% reduced. Locality pay limited.
    1996: ECI of 2.4% reduced. Locality pay limited.
    1997: Full ECI. Locality pay limited.
    1998: ECI of 2.8% reduced. Locality pay limited.
    1999: Full ECI. Locality pay limited.
    2000: Full ECI. Locality pay limited.

    Current Perspectives (2)

    • Pay Adjustments
      • Employees move with the pay structure (Structural Adjustment)
        • structure adjusted by uniform percentage amount
        • annual frequency (aligned to the calendar year, not fiscal year)
      • Employees move within the pay structure (Individual Adjustment)
        • within-grade increases
        • quality-step increases
        • promotions
    • Market strategy
      • FEPCA locality pay phase in
        • actual - 33.5 percent (2000)
        • statutory timetable - 90 percent (2001)
      • 2001 locality pay rates reflect the 1999 recommendation of the Federal Salary Council and Presidents Pay Agent as adjusted by the President and/or Congress.

    Pay Administration Notes

    • Step 4 on the base General Schedule for each GS grade is the Representative rate used for Highest Previous Rate (HPR) and reduction-in-force (RIF) determinations.

    • Red Circle Rates (above step 10)
      • grade retention
      • pay retention

    • Blue Circle Rates (below step 1)
      • are not permitted in the General Schedule

    For More Information