Skip to page navigation
U.S. flag

An official website of the United States government

Official websites use .gov
A .gov website belongs to an official government organization in the United States.

Secure .gov websites use HTTPS
A lock ( ) or https:// means you’ve safely connected to the .gov website. Share sensitive information only on official, secure websites.

Historical Record and Explanatory Material

This section describes the development of this Position Classification Flysheet for the Management and Program Analysis Series. This section will highlight some key dates and milestones and provide information about revisions to the Flysheet.

Background and Purpose

OPM updated this flysheet to align with skills-based hiring initiatives. The new competency-based framework embeds general, technical, and emerging competencies directly into classification standards, ensuring clearer knowledge requirements, more consistent grade determinations, and stronger support for modern hiring and assessment practices.

Competency-Based Classification Overview

Competency-based classification focuses on the capabilities required for successful job performance. By integrating current competencies into occupational structures, the framework reflects evolving mission needs, technologies, and work environments. It provides a clearer, more consistent foundation for defining work, distinguishing responsibility levels, and supporting transparent classification decisions.

Relationship to Qualifications and Assessment

Competencies serve as the connective tissue across classification, qualifications, and assessment:

  1. In classification, they define required knowledge and help determine series and grade.
  2. In qualification policy, they set minimum proficiency expectations.
  3. In assessment, they form the basis for evaluating applicants’ skills, behaviors, and abilities.

This integration strengthens merit-based hiring by emphasizing demonstrated capability over credentials alone.

Competencies, KSAs, and Classification

Competencies translate underlying knowledge, skills, and abilities (KSAs) into observable performance indicators. Embedding competency models, especially within Factor 1 (Knowledge Required), supports more accurate descriptions of work, clearer grade differentiation, and improved consistency across related occupations.

Supporting Workforce Agility and Modernization

Competency-based standards enhance the Federal workforce’s adaptability by evolving more quickly than traditional narrative standards. They help agencies:

  1. Respond to changing mission priorities and new technologies.
  2. Advance modernization efforts, including digital and data driven work.
  3. Ensure employees possess the capabilities necessary to meet strategic goals.

Overall, competency-based classification helps build a more agile, capable, and mission aligned workforce.

This update embeds general competencies into the classification structure through the complementing Competency-Based Group Qualifications Standard, identify technical competencies and align with specific OPM issued competency models; consolidates and clarifies the official titling provisions, including prefix use and the requirement that authorized titles be used without abbreviation or substitution; clarifies that series determination and titling provisions apply regardless of pay system while the grade level criteria apply to positions covered by the General Schedule; extends the grading guidance to grades not previously addressed; and updates the Impact of Automation section to reflect the role of data analytic tools and information systems in analytical and evaluative work and to reinforce that classification depends on the knowledge and skills required rather than on the tools used.

October 2024 Revision

The U.S. Office of Personnel Management previously worked in consultation with the Office of Management and Budget (OMB) to implement specific requirements of Public Law 115-435, Foundations for Evidence-Based Policymaking Act of 2018 (Evidence Act) resulting in the October 2024 revision of this guide. Policy established at that time remains intact in this update. In accordance with the Evidence Act, OPM conducted a study to identify key skills and competencies, establish or update an occupational series, and establish a new career path for program evaluation. Issuances for the skills and competencies and the career path for program evaluation work are separate from the classification policy guidance.

The Office of Management and Budget (OMB) Memorandum M-20-12, “Phase 4 Implementation of the Foundations for Evidence-Based Policymaking Act of 2018: Program Evaluation Standards and Practices,” provided examples of leading practices for agencies to draw upon as they build evaluation capacity, develop policies and procedures, and carry out evaluations to support evidence-based policymaking. The practices were selected for their potential usefulness in supporting agencies’ implementation of the program evaluation standards described in OMB M-20-12 (Appendix C). This set of practices outlined in M-20-12 is not meant to be exhaustive of the efforts an agency, office, or program could, should, or must undertake to ensure the quality and integrity of evaluation or adherence to legal or other requirements.

The Evidence Act established the role of the agency Evaluator Officer. Evaluation Officers have authority and responsibility for providing leadership over agencies' evaluation and Learning Agenda activities. As stated in the Evidence Act, the head of each CFO Act agency must designate a senior employee of the agency as the Evaluation Officer of the agency. This shall be done without regard to political affiliation and based on demonstrated expertise in evaluation methodology and practices and appropriate expertise to the disciplines of the agency. Non-CFO Act agencies, as well as sub-agencies, operational divisions, and bureaus of CFO Act Agencies are strongly encouraged to designate a qualified Evaluation Officer as appropriate.

In the context of the Evidence Act “Program evaluation” and “evaluation” are synonymous according to OMB (see OMB M-20-12, p 11). According to 5 U.S.C. § 311(3), the term “evaluation” signifies “an assessment using systematic data collection and analysis of one or more programs, policies, and organizations intended to assess their effectiveness and efficiency”. “Evaluation”, “program,” and other key terms are further described in OMB M-20-12, Appendix A.

In addition, the types of evaluation and some of the methods, and analysis used in evaluation are provided below (OMB M-20-12).

  1. Formative Evaluation is typically conducted to assess whether a program, policy, or organizational approach-or some aspect of these-is feasible, appropriate, and acceptable before it is fully implemented. It may include process and/or outcome measures. However, unlike outcome and impact evaluations, which seek to answer whether the program, policy, or organization met its intended goals or had the intended impacts, a formative evaluation focuses on learning and improvement and does not aim to answer questions of overall effectiveness.
  2. Impact Evaluation assesses the causal impact of a program, policy, or organization, or aspect thereof, on outcomes relative to those of a counterfactual. In other words, this type of evaluation estimates and compares outcomes with and without the program, policy, or organization, or aspect thereof. Impact evaluations include both experimental (i.e., randomized controlled trials) and quasi-experimental designs. An impact evaluation can help answer the question, "does it work, or did the intervention lead to the observed outcomes?"
  3. Intervention is a combination of program elements or strategies related to the design and implementation of programs and policies designed to produce specific results.
  4. Outcome Evaluation measures the extent to which a program, policy, or organization has achieved its intended outcome(s) and focuses on outputs and outcomes to assess effectiveness. Unlike impact evaluation above, it typically cannot discern causal attribution. Importantly, it is distinct from, but complementary to, performance measurement, as noted below. An outcome evaluation can help answer the question "Were the intended outcomes of the program, policy, or organization achieved?"

Per Section 101(a) of the Evidence Act, program evaluation is defined as “an assessment using systematic data collection and analysis of one or more programs, policies, and organizations intended to assess their effectiveness and efficiency.” Program Evaluator work includes, but is not limited to planning, managing, or conducting specific evaluation activities using complex and appropriate scientific methods; summarizing evaluation findings for agencywide/particular programs or policies; supporting other offices within an agency to interpret evaluation findings; and bringing evaluation-related evidence to bear in decision-making. The purpose of program evaluation is to assess the effectiveness or efficiency of a program, policy, organization or aspect of these. Evaluation can look beyond the program, policy, or organizational level to include assessment of particular projects or interventions within a program, for example, or particular aspects of a policy or functions or units within an organization. Evaluations may address questions related to the implementation or institution of a program, policy, or organization; the effectiveness or impact of specific strategies related to or used by a program, policy, or organization; and/or factors that relate to variability in the effectiveness of a program, policy, or organization or strategies of these. Evaluations can also examine questions related to understanding the contextual factors surrounding a program, as well as how to effectively target specific populations or groups for a particular intervention. They can provide critical information to inform decisions about current and future programming, policies, and organizational operations. Importantly, evaluation can be used for learning and improvement, as well as for accountability purposes.

As described above, there are different types of program evaluation, each of which answers different types of questions and requires different methodological approaches. Table A.1 in OMB Memorandum, M-21-27: Evidence-Based Policymaking: Learning Agendas and Annual Evaluation Plans lays out a series of evidence-building questions, indicates what type of evaluation may be most appropriate, and suggests methodological approaches. Program evaluators use their expertise to refine evidence-building questions, identify the appropriate evaluation type, and select the scientifically-sound method that aligns to that evaluation type and question. To do so, they bring understanding and awareness of a range of methodological approaches, including, but not limited to pilot projects, ethnography, structured observations, qualitative interviews and focus groups, time studies, statistical analysis of program or participant data, community-based participatory research, randomized controlled trials, regression discontinuity design, propensity score matching, and difference-in-difference approaches.

In support of the requirements of the Evidence Act, OPM conducted a comprehensive study including fact-finding activities, data analysis, and stakeholder engagement with Federal agencies. The focus of the study was the staff role supporting Evaluation Officers and creation of this role. An environmental scan was conducted to explore classification of, and competencies and tasks needed for the performance of, program evaluation work.

To fulfill the requirement set forth in Public Law 115-435, OPM used an evidence-based approach to develop policy aligned with the requirements of the Evidence Act. A comprehensive review of the data and information collected from Federal agencies and our environmental scan informed the classification policy determination and identified the skills needed to perform program evaluation work. The following information will outline the main tenets of the classification work performed for this study. The key skills, competencies, and duties were identified by Federal agency and human resources subject matter experts as needed for performing program evaluation work governmentwide along with the requirements outlined in the Evidence Act and corresponding OMB guidance. OPM reviewed position descriptions, job analysis, job announcements and other pertinent materials and information to collect information on program evaluation work. OPM held focus groups and stakeholder engagement activities with Federal agencies and key stakeholders including agency program evaluation and human resources subject matter experts identified by OMB and the occupational study.

As a result of stakeholder engagement activities program evaluation work was identified as being performed as both a full-time and collateral duty by agencies. OPM included exclusion criteria based on the description of program evaluation work provided by OMB guidance to identify subject matter experts for the study along with the group of subject matter experts OMB identified with program evaluation expertise and knowledge. The subject matter experts identified by OMB served as a core reference group for this study. The work described in this standard to be titled “Program Evaluator” include full-time program evaluation work. Program Evaluation work was also described as including elements of multidisciplinary work based on OMB guidance (M-21-27). As further elaborated in OMB Memo M-20-12, program evaluator work includes the application of scientific principles and techniques to conduct and oversee the execution of evaluation studies to assess effectiveness and efficiency. The OPM study supported the multidisciplinary nature of program evaluation work. Agencies reported program evaluation work being performed in various occupational groups including positions in the following occupational groups and families:

  1. 0100 – Social Science, Psychology and Welfare Group
  2. 0200 – Human Resources Management Group
  3. 0300 – General Administrative, Clerical and Office Services Group
  4. 0400 – Natural Resources Management and Biological Sciences Group
  5. 0500 – Accounting and Budget Group
  6. 0600 – Medical, Hospital, Dental, and Public Health Group
  7. 0800 – Engineering and Architecture Group

OPM defines multidisciplinary work as a position involving duties and responsibilities closely related to more than one discipline. As a result, the position could be classifiable to two or more occupational series including in this case series involving professional (0101 series) and/or nonprofessional (0343) work based on the specific knowledge, skills and abilities required by the individual position. The nature of the work is such that people with training and experience in either two or more occupations may often be considered well-qualified to do the work (Interpretive Guidance for Cybersecurity Positions, pp 21 -22). In accordance with OMB Memo M-20-12 (p. 16), specialized program evaluation knowledge and expertise may come from advanced degrees in program evaluation or related fields with concentration studies in program evaluation or direct experience designing and conducting program evaluation may supplement or substitute for advanced degrees. Related fields may include public administration, public policy, implementation science, statistics, economics, social sciences, or other relevant academic disciplines.

The duties and responsibilities assigned to most positions are covered by one occupational series, and the series determination is clear. For these positions, the series represents the primary work of the position, the highest level of work performed, and the paramount qualifications required. Some positions, however, are a mix of duties and responsibilities covered by two or more occupational series and classified by more than one standard or guide. Often the appropriate series for these positions is a general series for the occupational group covering the type of work performed.

For positions whose duties fall in more than one occupational group, the most appropriate series for the position depends on consideration of a number of factors. For many of these positions the grade controlling duties will determine the series. Sometimes, however, the highest level of work performed does not represent the most appropriate series, and the series can be determined only after considering the paramount qualifications required, sources of recruitment and line of progression, the reason for establishing the position, and the background knowledge required.

Classification of program evaluation work requires distinguishing between professional and administrative work. This requires the proper analysis of positions duties/responsibilities and the qualifications required to perform the work upon entry into the position. Professional and administrative work include specific characteristics as described below. See also the Introduction to the Position Classification Standards (p. 9) for additional information.

Professional Work

Professional work requires knowledge in a field of science or learning characteristically acquired through education or training equivalent to a bachelor’s or higher degree with major study in or pertinent to the specialized field, as distinguished from general education. Work is professional when it requires the exercise of discretion, judgment, and personal responsibility for the application of an organized body of knowledge that is constantly studied to make new discoveries and interpretations, and to improve data, materials, and methods. When professional work is not inherent in a position, the position is classified in a nonprofessional series, based on the duties and responsibilities assigned and the qualifications required to do the work.

For example, the Social Sciences Series, GS-0101, involves professional work. Positions classified in the Social Sciences GS-0101 series covers positions the duties of which are to advise on, administer, supervise, or perform research or other professional and scientific work in one or any combination of the social sciences when such work is not classifiable in other series of the Social Science, Psychology, and Welfare Group, 0101.

Administrative Work

Administrative work involves the exercise of analytical ability, judgment, discretion, and personal responsibility, and the application of a substantial body of knowledge of principles, concepts, and practices applicable to one or more fields of administration or management. While these positions do not require specialized education, they do involve the type of skills (e.g., analytical, research, writing, judgment) typically gained through a college level education, or through progressively responsible experience. Employees engaged in administrative work are concerned with analyzing, evaluating, modifying, and developing the basic programs, policies, and procedures which facilitate the work of Federal agencies and their programs. They apply a knowledge of administrative analysis, theory, and principles in adapting practice to the unique requirements of a particular program.

For example, the Management and Program Analysis Series, GS-0343, includes administrative work and positions that primarily serve as analysts and advisors to management on the evaluation of the effectiveness of government programs and operations, the productivity and efficiency of the management of Federal agencies, or both. Positions in the 0343 series require knowledge of the substantive nature of agency programs and activities; agency missions, policies, and objectives; management principles and processes; and the analytical and evaluative methods and techniques for assessing program development or execution and improving organizational effectiveness and efficiency.

Below is an additional comparison of professional and administrative work.

Professional Administrative
  1. Work requires specialized educational preparation as a prerequisite to perform the work.

There are situations in which an employee meets the formal education requirements for a particular professional field but does not perform professional work. This may be due to a lack of professional work to be done, or it may be because the organization and structure of the assignment do not require a professionally qualified employee. In such situations, the position is classified in an appropriate nonprofessional series, based on the duties and responsibilities assigned and the qualifications required to do the work.

  1. Work does not require specialized educational preparation, it does require a high degree of qualitative and/or quantitative analytical skills, the ability to research problems and issues, written and oral communication skills, and the application of mature judgment in problem solving.

It is important to note that positions formerly classified to the Program Analysis Series, 0345, were merged with the 0343 series in August 1990. The current 0343 series combined, in one occupation, positions which were found to perform similar duties and require many of the same, or closely related, knowledge, skills and abilities.

In summary the series determination is informed by agency needs and missions as well as the knowledge, skills, and abilities (KSAs)/competencies needed to perform the work. The KSAs/competencies drive the path to skill acquisition. Agencies have reported challenges and successes using different occupational series to classify Program Evaluation work. As defined in the Evidence Act, program evaluation is “an assessment using systematic data collection and analysis of one or more programs, policies, and organizations intended to assess their effectiveness and efficiency.” Also, the OMB Guidance directed the appointment of Evaluation Officers with expertise in evaluation methods and practices and documented expertise to the disciplines of the agency. These core factors were considered as well as specific agency needs. OPM collected data on the classification of program evaluation work directly from Federal agencies and external credible data and information as well. OMB Memorandum M-19-23 identified the roles and responsibilities of the agency Evaluation Officer, while OMB Memo M-21-27 further elaborated on the role by emphasizing that “the role should be filled by a senior career employee with skills and expertise to maintain principles of scientific integrity throughout the evaluation process, ensure adherence to the agency evaluation policy, and maintain the standards in OMB M-20-12.” (p. 4). OPM’s role was to extrapolate these functions to staff employees at the agency headquarters level and when appropriate at other levels within the organization to support the Evaluation Officer function and program evaluation work performed by the agency. Our study supported OMBs description of program evaluation work being aligned with disciplines of an agency. For example, agencies with healthcare missions may classify work in medical and healthcare occupational series and agencies with missions aligned with social sciences may classify their program evaluation in a social sciences’ occupational series. Therefore, the work is multidisciplinary in nature. Multidisciplinary includes specific characteristics that are not necessarily adaptable to one construct. Instead, the work is reflective of experience gained through various means and represents a compilation of functions and work roles. These work roles include a mixture of educational and non-educational requirements or experiences that may be acquired academically or in a professional setting.

The skills and qualification requirements for program evaluation work are driven by the classification series determination. OPM found that program evaluation work is multidisciplinary, and the work outlined in the Evidence Act and OMB Guidance M-20-12 is covered by the Management and Program Analysis Series, GS-0343, and other series, including the Social Science Series, 0101. Other series may also be used to classify program evaluation positions when supported by a job analysis and aligned with the agency’s mission.

Therefore, agencies must determine through a job analysis the qualification requirements for program evaluation work classified in the 0343 Series in conjunction with OPM General Schedule Qualifications Policy (i.e., General Schedule Qualifications Operating Manual and the Administrative Group Qualifications Standard). Agencies should follow qualification policy guidance for other series outside of the 0343 series, including the 0101 Social Science Series and others when used to classify program evaluation work.

The work identified through the environmental scan, focus groups, surveys, review and analysis of 84 position descriptions supplied by Agencies, and 21 OPM appeal decisions for similar work discussed previously indicate program evaluation work is multidisciplinary and aligned with the main tenets of program evaluation work. Program evaluation work is Administrative when covered by the Management and Program Analysis Series, GS-0343 and Professional when subject matter knowledge is needed to perform the work when supported by a job analysis and aligned with the agency’s mission.

The duties/responsibilities/tasks and qualifications required to perform program evaluation work identified as Administrative through the environmental scan, focus groups and surveys of typical Program Evaluator and Program Evaluation work definitions provided in Evidence-Based Policymaking Act of 2018 (5 U.S.C. 311 (3) and OMB M-20-12 compare favorably to an existing series and are directly covered by the intended coverage of Management and Program Analysis Series, 0343.

Positions performing work requiring specialized program subject matter knowledge are most appropriately classified in the respective specialized program subject matter series, for example, the Social Science Series, 0101, which would be driven by qualification requirements established by a job analysis in accordance with 5 CFR § 300.103 Basic requirements.

Crosswalk of Changes – General Occupational Information

The following crosswalk identifies revisions to the list of duties in the General Occupational Information section, showing the original language and the new language. Changes remove a duplicate fragment and consolidate duties with overlapping content.

# Duty Area Original Language New Language Type of Change
1 Management information / reporting systems reporting systems including the systems specifications, data gathering and analytical techniques, and systems evaluation methodology; Deleted. Duplicate fragment of the retained duty “analyzing management information requirements to develop program or administrative reporting systems including the systems specifications, data gathering and analytical techniques, and systems evaluation methodology.” Deleted (exact duplicate)
2 Conducting and managing evaluations

conducting program evaluations that are impartial, independent and credible and that meet Federal and professional standards;

managing evaluations to ensure they are impartial, independent, and credible and meet Federal and professional standards;

conducting or managing program evaluations that are impartial, independent, and credible and that meet Federal and professional standards; Consolidated (2 into 1)
3 Evaluation design

designing rigorous and feasible evaluations that address the identified research questions;

developing management and/or program evaluation plans, procedures, and methodology;

planning the design and methods used to conduct evaluation studies aligned to achieve intended goals of the studies;

designing rigorous and feasible management and/or program evaluations, including evaluation plans, procedures, methods, and methodology, that address the identified research questions and achieve the intended goals of the studies; Consolidated (3 into 1)
4 Expert input

consulting with technical work group/expert groups, to obtain input on the merit of the evaluation design, its implementation, planned analyses, and findings;

engaging expert consultants throughout the evaluation lifecycle as part of technical work groups, expert groups, or peer reviews;

consulting with and engaging expert consultants throughout the evaluation lifecycle as part of technical work groups, expert groups, or peer reviews to obtain input on the merit of the evaluation design, its implementation, planned analyses, and findings; Consolidated (2 into 1)
5 Resource requirements

determining resource requirements (for example, staffing, funding, equipment) based on program or project objectives or operational needs;

identifying resources (staff, funding, equipment, facilities) required to support varied levels of program operations;

determining resource requirements (for example, staffing, funding, equipment, facilities) based on program or project objectives or operational needs, including resources required to support varied levels of program operations; Consolidated (2 into 1)
6 Program or policy effectiveness

analyzing and evaluating (on a quantitative or qualitative basis) the effectiveness of program operations or policy in meeting established goals and objectives;

evaluating the efficiency or effectiveness of programs, policies, or organizations;

analyzing and evaluating (on a quantitative or qualitative basis) the efficiency or effectiveness of programs, program operations, policies, or organizations in meeting established goals and objectives; Consolidated (2 into 1)
7 Impact of laws and regulations

analyzing new or proposed legislation or regulations to determine impact on program operations and management;

evaluating the impact of changes to laws, regulations, policies, standards, or procedures, including, for example, costs or benefits;

evaluating the impact of new, proposed, or changed laws, regulations, policies, standards, or procedures on program operations and management, including, for example, costs or benefits; Consolidated (2 into 1)
Control Panel